
A tip is money you choose to give. A service charge is an amount the business adds to the bill. “Gratuity” usually means a tip, but an “automatic gratuity” printed on a bill is really a service charge. If a service charge is already on your bill, you usually don’t need to tip again.
Calculate it: if you do decide to tip on top, use the tip calculator on the food and drink subtotal, not on the service charge.
The three terms
| Term | Who decides the amount? | Optional? | Typical example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tip | You | Yes | 18% added on the card slip |
| Gratuity | You (usually) | Yes | Another word for a tip |
| Automatic gratuity | The business | No, unless removed | 18% added for a party of 8 |
| Service charge | The business | Depends on the country and wording | “Discretionary service charge 12.5%” (UK) |
How the IRS draws the line (US)
The IRS says a payment is a tip only if all four of these are true:
- It’s made free from compulsion: the customer isn’t required to pay it.
- The customer has the unrestricted right to decide the amount.
- It isn’t negotiated or dictated by employer policy.
- The customer generally has the right to decide who receives it.
If any of these is missing, it may be a service charge. That’s why the IRS treats an automatic gratuity on a large party as a service charge. Service charges paid to staff count as wages, not tips. See Automatic Gratuity for Large Parties Explained.
Reading the receipt: three examples
US restaurant, party of eight
- Subtotal $420.00 · Gratuity 18% $75.60 · Tax · Tip line: ______
The 18% is already added. Leave the tip line blank or add only a small extra for exceptional service.
UK restaurant
- Food and drink £96.00 · “Optional service charge 12.5%” £12.00
This is the tip. If you’re unhappy with the service, you can ask for an optional charge to be removed. Since 1 October 2024, the Employment (Allocation of Tips) Act 2023 requires employers in England, Scotland and Wales to pass tips, gratuities and service charges to workers in full, without deductions. See Tipping in the UK.
Italy, Spain or France
- Menu or bill says “servizio incluso” or “service compris”
Service is included. Rick Steves notes that a small extra tip is only for great service: about 5% is adequate and 10% is generous. See Tipping in Europe.
Other charges that aren’t tips
- Delivery fees and app service fees usually go to the platform.
- “Wellness” or “kitchen appreciation” fees go to the business, which decides how to use them.
- Taxes and municipality fees, such as those on bills in Dubai, go to the government. See Tipping in Dubai and the UAE.
FAQ
Can I refuse to pay a service charge? It depends on the country and wording. A charge labelled optional or discretionary can usually be removed if you ask. A mandatory charge printed on the menu generally can’t.
Does the server get the service charge? In the UK, the law now requires it to be passed to workers. In the US, a service charge belongs to the business, which may pay some or all of it to staff as wages.
Should I tip on top of a service charge? Not normally. An extra tip is for service well above the norm.
Written and fact-checked by Zeeshan Nawaz · Last reviewed: 15 Nov 2026
Sources
- IRS, Tips versus service charges: how to report: https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/tips-versus-service-charges-how-to-report
- GOV.UK, Distributing tips fairly: statutory code of practice: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/distributing-tips-fairly-statutory-code-of-practice
- Rick Steves, Tipping in Europe: https://www.ricksteves.com/travel-tips/money/tipping-in-europe


